Quick answer
Am I dealing with a factory or a trader, and does it matter?
A factory that makes hookah coals can show five things a trader cannot, from a registered production address to shipping papers in its own name. Each of the five can be checked from a desk: on a map, in the registry and on a video call. Buying through a trader is not a fault in itself; what matters is knowing which one you are dealing with.
1. Five things only a factory can show
A seller can show a product, a price and a box. Only a maker can show where and how the product is made. The table gives the five things, each with this factory's answer.
| What a factory can show | This factory's answer |
|---|---|
| A production address that matches the registration | Jl. Nasional 14 No.14, Kaliran, Blondo, Kec. Mungkid, Kabupaten Magelang, Jawa Tengah 56512, Indonesia; registration number (NIB) 9120408273615 |
| Its own equipment | 6 drying ovens fired with wood pellets |
| Named production staff | Production is run by Doni Setiawan, Production Manager |
| A live walk-through of the line | Offered by video call, on request |
| Shipping papers signed in its own name | The weathering certificate is signed by Dwi Saputro, Logistics and Shipping Coordinator |
The people behind the answers are listed on the page of the people at the factory.
2. How to check each one from your desk
None of the five needs a flight. Four steps check them from a desk.
-
Find the address on a map
Look for the plant at the address you were given. A production site looks like one from above and from the road.
-
Look the company up in the registry
Use the registration number and compare the legal name and the address with the ones on your quote.
-
Ask for a live video call from the floor
Ask to see the press, the ovens and the weathering area in one continuous walk.
-
Ask who signs the papers
Ask for the name and job title of the person who signs the weathering certificate, and look for that name on a past certificate.
For this factory, the registration number and the registry steps are on the page about how to verify the company, and a call is asked for on the page about a visit or a video call.
Important
Ask for a live call, not a recorded video. A recording shows a plant; a live call shows that the person you are dealing with can walk into it.
3. When a trader is fine
Buying through a trader is a choice with reasons, not a mistake.
Definition
trading company
A trading company is a business that sells goods made by others and has no production site of its own.
- Small volumes. A factory that sells by the full container cannot serve a buyer who needs less.
- Mixed loads. A trader can put several products from several makers into one shipment.
- Credit and local service. A trader near you may offer terms and stock that a maker far away does not.
Note
What costs a buyer is not the trader. It is not knowing who makes the product, because then nobody can be asked about a batch.
4. What to ask either one
Whichever you buy from, ask who makes the product, where, and who signs the shipping papers. A trader who answers those three has told you what you need to know.
The full list of questions, with this factory's answers, is in the guide of questions to ask a factory. What to check before money moves is in the guide to supplier fraud patterns.
Tip
Write the maker's name into your purchase order, even when you buy through a trader. A paper that names the maker can be checked against the cartons.